I summarized the outcome of this discussions here, and will close this topic. In regard to staking voting I still want to refer to following link, https://hackernoon.com/voting-determines-the-conversation-how-to-think-about-staking-tokens-3f152185313a where also some issues being discribed which later might become of interest as well (e.g. 14-( C))

Herewith I close this discussion and will sum the outcome as follows: Particl Community Forum will be choosen as primary choice for proposals and structured community discussions

@btmr said in 8-(D) - Repetetive proposals when denied: Ok, then let’s get rid of that damn second round for now Only to make sure we talk of the same voting causes. During final “voting period” there’s a “second” vote done by stake voting and outgoing transaction voting. During “proposal period” I still would do some preliminary selection or ranking, also based on a kind of voting (either funding or number of outgoing transactions), thus making it easier during “voting period” to distinguish between serious and spam proposals. Maybe you as voter during the “voting period” have only limited time and thus want only voting for the top 5 proposals and so ignoring the remaining x-hundred proposals. The benefit of funding I see in the increased amount of “skin” you can put into the game If you or any other community member think your proposal is really important to make a decision on, you can support it in an easy way with a significant amount of PART by one single transactions to the proposals specific address. When doing this by outgoing transactions with a fixed amount, you might have to send many transactions to signal your opinion of a high importance for this specific proposal. I agree, if one kind of ranking would be sufficient, it would be easier when not having the need for weighting in some form. Have a nice weekend

I again summarized the points mentioned. I emphasized the need for a trustless long-time storage medium for each proposal. Thus I prefered to use the particl blockchain instead of any third party provider, as e.g. github. I will temporarily leave this topic up for discussion and will close then in a few days.